top of page

$950,000 Settlement — Negligent Supervision Claim Involving a School District

Writer: DMM Law
DMM Law
Dec 8, 2023
2 min read

Updated: 21 hours ago

Timothy J. McNichols of DMM Law Firm obtained a settlement of $950,000 in a negligent supervision claim involving a school district, in which the injured student suffered partial blindness.


When a child is hurt at school because supervision falls short, the consequences can last a lifetime. Claims like these demand a careful investigation and a legal team that will see the case through for the family.


Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is different and is evaluated on its own facts. In personal injury cases, you pay no attorney's fee unless we obtain a recovery for you. Free consultation.


The Law Behind the Result

This settlement resolved a negligent supervision claim against a school district, arising from a school sporting event. Schools stand in place of parents during the school day, and New Jersey law holds them to a duty of reasonable supervision — enough attentive oversight, matched to the students' ages and the activity, to guard against foreseeable harm.

For school sports, the standard a coach is judged by comes from the New Jersey Supreme Court's decision in Morgan Dennehy v. East Windsor Regional Board of Education (2022): ordinary negligence, which is the regular duty to act with reasonable care. Before Dennehy, sports cases were often measured against a higher standard that was much harder for an injured student to prove — something close to recklessness. Dennehy replaced it with the same reasonableness test used in most injury cases, and it is the standard this case was evaluated under.

Because a school district is a public entity, these claims also run through the New Jersey Tort Claims Act, the law governing claims against government bodies. It imposes strict early deadlines — a formal notice of claim is generally due within 90 days of the incident (N.J.S.A. 59:8-8) — and missing one can end a case before it starts.

Recent Posts

See All
$250,000 Settlement — Sidewalk Slip and Fall

Timothy J. McNichols of DMM Law Firm obtained a settlement of $250,000 for a client who suffered serious orthopedic injuries in a slip and fall involving a raised sidewalk. A raised sidewalk may look

 
 

609-971-1010

© 2026 Dasti, McGuckin, McNichols, Connors, Anthony & Buckley

bottom of page