top of page

$100,000 Settlement — Retail Store Slip and Fall on a Wet Floor

Writer: DMM Law
DMM Law
Sep 17
2 min read

Updated: 21 hours ago

Our client slipped and fell on a wet floor in a retail store, suffering a knee injury. Timothy J. McNichols of DMM Law Firm obtained a settlement of $100,000.


Cases like this are where New Jersey's mode of operation rule can matter. Ordinarily, someone hurt in a fall has to prove the property owner knew — or should have known — about the hazard. But when a store's self-service way of doing business creates the risk of exactly that kind of hazard, the rule says the injured shopper does not have to prove the store knew about that particular spill. The risk is built into how the store operates — and the store, not the shopper, answers for it.


Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is different and is evaluated on its own facts. In personal injury cases, you pay no attorney's fee unless we obtain a recovery for you. Free consultation.



The Law Behind the Result

Ordinarily, a shopper who falls in a store must prove the store knew about the hazard — or that it had been there long enough that the store should have known.

New Jersey's mode of operation rule is the exception. When a store's self-service way of doing business creates the risk of the very hazard that caused the fall — loose produce, self-serve drinks, merchandise customers handle themselves — the injured shopper does not have to prove the store knew about that particular spill or item on the floor. The thinking is simple: a business that profits from a self-service model takes on the risks that come with it, and stays responsible for keeping its floors safe within it.

The modern cases bookend the rule. In Nisivoccia v. Glass Gardens, Inc., 175 N.J. 559 (2003) — the grape case — a shopper slipped on loose grapes near a supermarket checkout, and the Supreme Court held that the mode of operation rule gave her an inference of negligence without proof the store knew the grapes were on the floor: when customers serve themselves from open displays, spillage is foreseeable, and it is the store that must come forward and show it took reasonable care against it. The Court then drew the rule's boundary in Prioleau v. Kentucky Fried Chicken, Inc., 223 N.J. 245 (2015), refusing to apply the rule to a customer who fell on a wet floor on her way to a KFC restroom, because the hazard had no connection to any self-service part of the business. Together, the two cases state the test that decides claims like this one: the hazard must grow out of the way the business has its customers serve themselves.

Recent Posts

See All
$250,000 Settlement — Sidewalk Slip and Fall

Timothy J. McNichols of DMM Law Firm obtained a settlement of $250,000 for a client who suffered serious orthopedic injuries in a slip and fall involving a raised sidewalk. A raised sidewalk may look

 
 

609-971-1010

© 2026 Dasti, McGuckin, McNichols, Connors, Anthony & Buckley

bottom of page