$160,000 Settlement — Bar Slip and Fall, and Why Early Notice Matters

Updated: 21 hours ago
Our client slipped and fell on a wet dance floor in a bar and suffered an ankle injury. Timothy J. McNichols of DMM Law Firm settled the case in May 2021 for $160,000.
This case is also a lesson in why early notice matters. Soon after the fall, we sent the bar a preservation of evidence letter — a formal demand that it keep everything relevant to the incident, including the surveillance video and the condition of the flooring. The bar owner destroyed evidence anyway, after receiving that letter.
When evidence disappears, it changes a case, and New Jersey law takes that seriously. It's called spoliation of evidence. The sooner an attorney is involved after a fall, the sooner that preservation notice goes out — and the harder it is for the proof to vanish. And when proof does vanish, there are sanctions for failing to preserve it.
Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Every case is different and is evaluated on its own facts. In personal injury cases, you pay no attorney's fee unless we obtain a recovery for you. Free consultation.
The Law Behind the Result
A bar, like any business, owes its customers reasonably safe premises — floors included. Spills are inevitable in a bar, which is why the duty includes keeping an eye out for them, cleaning them up promptly, and warning patrons or closing off an area until it is dry. A wet dance floor that nobody tends to is the kind of condition this duty is aimed at.
These cases are also won and lost on proof, which is why the preservation letter described above matters. What happened here shows why. After being told in writing to preserve the evidence, the bar ripped out the dance floor and replaced it completely — so no expert could ever inspect the surface our client fell on. Destroying evidence that matters to a case is called spoliation. The duty to preserve evidence arises when litigation is pending or likely and the party knows the evidence is relevant — which is exactly what a preservation letter establishes, in writing. And it makes no difference whether the destruction was deliberate or merely careless: intent does not affect liability, only the remedy. Cockerline v. Menendez, 411 N.J. Super. 596 (App. Div. 2010). The party that destroys evidence can be sanctioned, and a jury is permitted to infer that the destroyed evidence would have hurt that party's case.
